1968 (2-2): Dennis Painter (OG), Cliff Hogan (DB)
1969 (2-4): Jeff Davis (OT), Cliff Hogan (DB) 
1970 (3-7): Jeff Davis (OT), Joe Speroni (DB), Jay Jewell (DB)
1971 (7-14): Tom Sartori (OE), Randy Hardy (RB), Carl Sanfilippo (DT), Mike Pecora (MG), Jay Jewell (DB), Joe Caruso, Ron Wojtowicz (RB) 
1972 (4-18): Stu Davis (OE), John Weir (OT), Ron Wojtowicz (RB), Mark Sartori (LB)
1973 (4-22): Chuck Meissner (OG), John Weir (OT), Jack Hager (DE), Mark Sartori (LB)
1974 (3-25): Vince Olivero (OG), Ron Dolecki (DE), Chuck Meissner (OL)
1975 (3-28): Joe Roosa (OG), Jim O'Rourke (DL), Brad Weitzel (DB)
1976 (4-32): Jud Hager (OL), Bob Paprocki (RB), John O'Rourke (DL), Mark Dry (LB)
1977 (5-37): Jay Weitzel (LB), Joel Quattrone (DB), Todd Hager (OL), Chris Myers (OL), Dan Dry (RB)
1978 (3-40): Chris Myers (OL), Pete Lee (OL), Bud Herrick (DL)
1979 (2-42): Pete Lee (OL), Todd Bullers (DB)
1980 (1-43): John Cappelino (OL)
1981 (2-45): Todd Heidrick (QB), Jim Mendell (RB)
1982 (6-51): Mack MacLeod (OL), Jay Haley (OL), Todd Heidrick (QB), Chris Krantz (RB), Jim Knaus (DL), Dave Zariczny (LB)
1983 (1-52): Todd Titus (DB)
1984 (3-55): Joe Myers (OL), Carl Agnelli (RB), Mike Whitcher (DE)
1985 (1-56): Mike John (LB)
1986 (4-60): Ray Haley (OL), Joe Bierfeldt (RB), Mike Stoeckel (DL), Pat Hogan (DB)
1987 (5-65): Chris Gilfillan (OL), Paul Myers (C), Mark Halftown (QB), Paul Furlong (RB), Travis Heron (LB)
1988 (3-68): Pete Siperek (OL), Jim Magara (DE), Kyle Lester (LB)
1989 (4-72): T.J. Brol (LB), D.J. Leiper (DB), Jene Oyer (OL), Arron Whitmmore (DE)
1990 (5-77): Jeff Krantz (QB), T.J. Brol (RB), Jason Marsh (OE), Jean Oyer (OL), Steve Emborsky (C)
1991 (3-80): Mike Ficek (QB), Bob Kurek (RB), Chris Barney (OL)
1992 (3-83): Mike Ficek (DB), Jeremy John (OL), Ed Vassar (RB)
1993 (2-85): Tom Callen (DE), Paul Haley (LB)
1994 (1-86): Todd Krantz (LB)
1995 (1-87): Thad Grabowski (DB)
1996 (3-90): Dave Osborne (OL), Eric Dulanski (DE), Darren Ross (LB)
1997 (1-91): Darren Ross (LB)
1998 (3-94): Chad Bartoszek (OE), Logan Pascarella (LB), Adam Weitzel (K/P)
1999 (5-99): Chris Drugg (RB), Josh Hostuttler (LB), Marty Jacobson (DL), Andy Murphy (OL), Jason Siafakas (DB)
2000 (5-104): Victor Arena (LB), Aaron Deboy (C), Cameron Haines (DB), Dustin Ross (RB), Kyle Scott (E)
2001 (4-108): Aaron Deboy (C), Cameron Haines (DB), Mike Liberatore (LB), Dustin Ross (RB)
2004 (1-109): Justin Hager (LB)
2005 (1-110): Billy Roosa (SE)
2006 (1-111): Mike Crandall (DB)
2007 (1-112): Tyler Smith (DB)
2009 (1-113): Carmen Papa (RB)
2010 (1-114): Ben Haas (LB)
2011 (2-116): Ben Haas (RB), Tanner John (DB)
2012 (3-119): Tanner John (QB), Dusty Lewis (DE), Cameron Caputi (LB)
2013 (1-120): Brad Cunninham (DE)
2017: Tyler Hedlund (LB)
2018: Tyler Hedlund (DB), Ira John (LB)
2021: Jesse Stahlman (RB), Kody Shinners (DL)
2022: Jesse Stahlman (RB), Jaxon Tarr (DE), Tayoni Galante (LB)
2023: Arlen Newark (WR), Zach Treitley (LB), Cory Holleran (DB)
2024: Zach Treitley (LB), Cory Holleran (DB), Xavier Peters (RB), Maddox Isaac (QB), Warrick Kyler (OL)

Big 30 Coach of the Year Award
1964: Joe Sanfilippo
1971: Joe Sanfilippo
1982: George Whitcher
1993: George Whitcher
2001: Rich Morton
2011: Jason Marsh
2023: Chad Bartoszek
2024: Chad Bartoszek
*Bartoszek is currently the only four-time Coach of the Year in Big 30 annals (also winning it in 2014 and ’15 as the head coach at Franklinville-Ellicottville). Bartozek’s list of awards and accomplishments are long. He was the Big 30 Coach of the Year in 2014, 2015, 2023, 2024. In addition, he was the 2023 WNNY Coach of the Year, 2023 Buffalo Bills Coach of the Year, and League Coach of the Year in 2014, 2015, 2021, 2022, and 2023.

Big 30 Player of the Year Award
1965: Bob Nugent
1967: Chuck Christ
1970: Jeff Davis
1977: Dan Dry
1982: Jay Haley (LOY)
1984: Don John (LOY)
1986: Ray Haley (LOY)
1987: Chris Gillfillan (LOY)
1989: Arron Whitmore (DPOY)
1990: TJ Brol
1992: Jeremy John (LOY)
1999: Jason Siafakas (DPOY)
2001: Dustin Ross
2004: Justin Hager (DPOY)
2021: Kody Shinners (LOY)
2024: Cory Holleran (DPOY)