1968 (2-2): Dennis Painter (OG), Cliff Hogan (DB)
1969 (2-4): Jeff Davis (OT), Cliff Hogan (DB) 
1970 (3-7): Jeff Davis (OT), Joe Speroni (DB), Jay Jewell (DB)
1971 (7-14): Tom Sartori (OE), Randy Hardy (RB), Carl Sanfilippo (DT), Mike Pecora (MG), Jay Jewell (DB), Joe Caruso, Ron Wojtowicz (RB) 
1972 (4-18): Stu Davis (OE), John Weir (OT), Ron Wojtowicz (RB), Mark Sartori (LB)
1973 (4-22): Chuck Meissner (OG), John Weir (OT), Jack Hager (DE), Mark Sartori (LB)
1974 (3-25): Vince Olivero (OG), Ron Dolecki (DE), Chuck Meissner (OL)
1975 (3-28): Joe Roosa (OG), Jim O'Rourke (DL), Brad Weitzel (DB)
1976 (4-32): Jud Hager (OL), Bob Paprocki (RB), John O'Rourke (DL), Mark Dry (LB)
1977 (5-37): Jay Weitzel (LB), Joel Quattrone (DB), Todd Hager (OL), Chris Myers (OL), Dan Dry (RB)
1978 (3-40): Chris Myers (OL), Pete Lee (OL), Bud Herrick (DL)
1979 (2-42): Pete Lee (OL), Todd Bullers (DB)
1980 (1-43): John Cappelino (OL)
1981 (2-45): Todd Heidrick (QB), Jim Mendell (RB)
1982 (6-51): Mack MacLeod (OL), Jay Haley (OL), Todd Heidrick (QB), Chris Krantz (RB), Jim Knaus (DL), Dave Zariczny (LB)
1983 (1-52): Todd Titus (DB)
1984 (3-55): Joe Myers (OL), Carl Agnelli (RB), Mike Whitcher (DE)
1985 (1-56): Mike John (LB)
1986 (4-60): Ray Haley (OL), Joe Bierfeldt (RB), Mike Stoeckel (DL), Pat Hogan (DB)
1987 (5-65): Chris Gilfillan (OL), Paul Myers (C), Mark Halftown (QB), Paul Furlong (RB), Travis Heron (LB)
1988 (3-68): Pete Siperek (OL), Jim Magara (DE), Kyle Lester (LB)
1989 (4-72): T.J. Brol (LB), D.J. Leiper (DB), Jene Oyer (OL), Arron Whitmmore (DE)
1990 (5-77): Jeff Krantz (QB), T.J. Brol (RB), Jason Marsh (OE), Jean Oyer (OL), Steve Emborsky (C)
1991 (3-80): Mike Ficek (QB), Bob Kurek (RB), Chris Barney (OL)
1992 (3-83): Mike Ficek (DB), Jeremy John (OL), Ed Vassar (RB)
1993 (2-85): Tom Callen (DE), Paul Haley (LB)
1994 (1-86): Todd Krantz (LB)
1995 (1-87): Thad Grabowski (DB)
1996 (3-90): Dave Osborne (OL), Eric Dulanski (DE), Darren Ross (LB)
1997 (1-91): Darren Ross (LB)
1998 (3-94): Chad Bartoszek (OE), Logan Pascarella (LB), Adam Weitzel (K/P)
1999 (5-99): Chris Drugg (RB), Josh Hostuttler (LB), Marty Jacobson (DL), Andy Murphy (OL), Jason Siafakas (DB)
2000 (5-104): Victor Arena (LB), Aaron Deboy (C), Cameron Haines (DB), Dustin Ross (RB), Kyle Scott (E)
2001 (4-108): Aaron Deboy (C), Cameron Haines (DB), Mike Liberatore (LB), Dustin Ross (RB)
2004 (1-109): Justin Hager (LB)
2005 (1-110): Billy Roosa (SE)
2006 (1-111): Mike Crandall (DB)
2007 (1-112): Tyler Smith (DB)
2009 (1-113): Carmen Papa (RB)
2010 (1-114): Ben Haas (LB)
2011 (2-116): Ben Haas (RB), Tanner John (DB)
2012 (3-119): Tanner John (QB), Dusty Lewis (DE), Cameron Caputi (LB)
2013 (1-120): Brad Cunninham (DE)
2017: Tyler Hedlund (LB)
2018: Tyler Hedlund (DB), Ira John (LB)
2021: Jesse Stahlman (RB), Kody Shinners (DL)
2022: Jesse Stahlman (RB), Jaxon Tarr (DE), Tayoni Galante (LB)
2023: Arlen Newark (WR), Zach Treitley (LB), Cory Holleran (DB)

Big 30 Coach of the Year Award
1964: Joe Sanfilippo
1971: Joe Sanfilippo
1982: George Whitcher
1993: George Whitcher
2001: Rich Morton
2011: Jason Marsh
2023: Chad Bartoszek

Big 30 Player of the Year Award
1965: Bob Nugent
1967: Chuck Christ
1970: Jeff Davis
1977: Dan Dry
1982: Jay Haley (LOY)
1984: Don John (LOY)
1986: Ray Haley (LOY)
1987: Chris Gillfillan (LOY)
1989: Arron Whitmore (DPOY)
1990: TJ Brol
1992: Jeremy John (LOY)
1999: Jason Siafakas (DPOY)
2001: Dustin Ross
2004: Justin Hager (DPOY)
2021: Kody Shinners (LOY)